PDA

View Full Version : D16Y8 vs B18A w/ minor mods



NSPYRE
18-11-2006, 08:25 PM
hey guys,

sorry to post such a question, but someone i know insists that his civic coupe with D16 will beat my DA9 B18A. personally, i dont kno wat will win so i decided to seek opinions from members of ozhonda. with such cars that perform similarly, i realise that it comes down to the driver's ability and launch. the B18A has a little bit more torque obviously becos of the slightly larger displacement. however, the B18A has only approximately 3kw more. also the kerb weight of the civic is 100kg less than the DA9.

the D16 is a SOHC vtec where as the B18A is a DOHC non-vtec. would this factor be significant in the outcome? would the higher red-line mean anything? reason why i havent taken it to the track yet is that we have a $350 wager. he's a lot more confident than i am, lol.

finally, the civic coupe is bone stock. i have a few minor mods on the DA9; 2.25" hi-flo cat w/ twin loop muffler (and yes, i do realise the exhaust system is only as strong as its weakest link). car runs 98 octane fuel with ignition timing set at 19 degrees (3 above stock. once again, there is debate whether this actually does anything).

anyways, i think that about covers it. opinions are appreciated, but none that are along the lines of "both of them are sh!t and slow" yes, they arent the fastest things ever made and i never said they were, but its just something i would like to know

- David

civicCXI
19-11-2006, 03:18 PM
DOHC is always better than SOHC and B is generally better than D. But vtec + lighter weight is always better than Non-vtec.
If i'm not wrong, B18A has 96 kw (+ ur mods) and D16 is around 88 kw.
Assuming that u both have the same driving skills, i'll put my money on u.

yourfather
19-11-2006, 03:24 PM
take it to the race track and go for your life.

silver_screen
19-11-2006, 05:04 PM
d16y8 makes 96kw and some 140 something nm

my moneys on the lighter civic

FR33K
19-11-2006, 05:16 PM
been there done that... ill put my money on you (considering you know how to drive)

silver_screen
19-11-2006, 05:50 PM
It can go both ways. Ive seen many tough d16's and ive built 1 a long time ago. It was quite quick. But then again, i can say the same for the B18 non Vtec... seen a few quick ones around, u may have the upper hand considering ur mods. But only a race will tell

bennjamin
19-11-2006, 08:11 PM
as said - go to the local track and get the results on PAPER for proof.

Otherwise dont make silly threads like this. Its the drive,r not the car :)