UPDATE: The outer skin ensolite applications and access hole covers described in this post have since been removed as they have failed and/or caused problems; more details in latest post (page ~9 of this thread)
my weekend ensolite project is done! not without its dramas but still fruitful, nonetheless.
the dynamat helped control the vibrations in the panels, but to get the dynamat applied in the doors i had to remove the factory acoustic foam over the access holes, essentially removing all soft surfaces from my doors and turning them into resonance boxes. not quite, as there was a reduction in noise, but i had sacrificed one good thing for another and i wasn't happy with that.
i imported some ensolite (a special 3mm closed-cell foam developed by NASA) from the states and intended to apply a couple of layers to each door, and then a good layer all over the floor and boot. i changed my mind however, and decided to focus my material in the doors as there were no soft materials there to absorb airborne soundwaves, whereas the floor had carpet all over it.
so for each door, i put 2 layers of ensolite against the outer skin, covered up the access holes with a dynamat+sheet metal+ensolite combo, covered up remaining access hole gaps with ensolite and then another final layer of ensolite over the top. for fixing the foam, i used a combination of strong double-stick tape, waterproof cloth tape and a special spray adhesive intended for foam.
piccies!! :p
Access hole covering
From top down: Ensolite, Al 0.6mm stucco, Dynamat Xtreme - UPDATE: 0.6mm Al, even with dynamat, still produces resonance problems. I wouldn't recommend anything thinner than 1.0mm from now on.
http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/256...rieryf4.th.jpg
Right rear
This door is always the first to cop any sort of treatment! i didn't quite put enough double-stick tape on the outer skin layers so they're bulging a bit; but not enough to foul the power window. (UPDATE: they eventually detached from the outer skin and did start fouling the power windows) Also used cloth tape to secure my access holes reinforcements, decided this was a bit dodgy but only after i covered the door up. i'll fix it later if they fall off :)
http://img99.imageshack.us/img99/427/ensrr1jp4.th.jpg
http://img226.imageshack.us/img226/6...srr2xq4.th.jpg
http://img226.imageshack.us/img226/7...srr3zx4.th.jpg
Right front
Again, didn't put enough double-stick on the outer skin layers, and there's less clearance for the power window here. tested it and seems ok though :)
http://img225.imageshack.us/img225/1...sfr1ys0.th.jpg
http://img99.imageshack.us/img99/856/ensfr2hd8.th.jpg
http://img152.imageshack.us/img152/6...sfr3xl9.th.jpg
Left rear
Note that in the last pic i forgot to cut out a hole in the foam for the hole that accepts the main door panel screw... oops
http://img226.imageshack.us/img226/6...srl1ck1.th.jpg
http://img99.imageshack.us/img99/2306/ensrl2xk1.th.jpg
http://img226.imageshack.us/img226/6...srl3ys0.th.jpg
Left front
This door caused the most trouble, took me 3 hours to disengage the clip inside the door handle, turns out the inner pin was turned 45 degrees so it wouldn't disengage, hammer+chopstick fixed the problem though.
http://img152.imageshack.us/img152/7...sfl1un3.th.jpg
http://img225.imageshack.us/img225/5...sfl2ty7.th.jpg
http://img152.imageshack.us/img152/5...sfl3qm1.th.jpg
RESULTS
an initial test drive with the gf found that the road noise is noticeably more subdued, but more impressive than that was the fact that the road noise has much 'smoother' sound to it. SQ improved as well.
SUMMARY
My car as of today has the following sound dampening mods done to it:
Defense pak sound protection ($500) - entire underbody of car
Dynamat Xtreme ($600) - 2-3 layers in doors, 2 in floor, 1 in boot
Ensolite ($200) - 4 layers in doors
Total cost: $1300
Total time: 3 full weekends
Next on the list:
- front wheel well tarring
- quiet tyres