Printable View
Due in for a service now, can get my hands on CASTROL EDGE TITANIUM FULL SYNTHETIC 5W-30 for only $30
***PROBLEM***
I have been hearing lots of negative feedback about this oil such as burning to fast and blowing to much smoke but could be not true cause my mate used this oil in his Integra and loved it.
Is it worth servicing my H22A with around 200,000ks on it with this oil? if not what else u reccomend???
200,000km is a tad high for such thin oil IMO
If your afraid of thick oils try penrite HPR 5 full synthetic 5w-40
isnt 5w-40 thick? so it will burn oil easy i think
5-40 is quite thin when hot.. i would try a 10-40'
thick generally doesn't burn as easily
Gonna disagree there.Quote:
Originally Posted by curtis265
A 5w40 and a 10w40 are going to be the same viscosity when hot. That's what the 40 is. The difference between them is the cold temp, which in this situation I'd agree with the 10w, as the 5w will burn more on initial start up.
my mistake had the wrong way
h22jet what sort of compression results do you have?
I've always used 10W-60 in both the h22a's that I've had. Recommended for a h22a is 5W-30.
Really don't be overly fussed by your oil choice, it's not like you're driving some fully built 17:1 comp ratio track monster and revving it out over 9000rpm all day.
I havnt checked my compression results, so if i get the castrol 5w-30 is it worth it or do you guys recommend something like 10w-30 or 10w-40? currently my car always has white smoke every morning for a few minutes as i let it idel while warming up engine
that oil is made for the 4 cylinder jap engines but lotsof people complain saying it burns there oil alot so that is why im here asking a question to know your experiences of oils
White smoke is normal in the morning. Especially on cold mornings & nights.
I use 0w-40 but if I can't get my hands on some, I'll settle for 10w-40.
Preludes tend to burn a bit of oil, you'll have to check the levels once every couple of weeks.
And I personally don't recommend idling the car to warm up the engine, esp a NA car. It does more harm than good and is pointless.
i must disagree that it cart harm an engine if you let it warm up, if you turn on your engine on a cold morning and just drive off the oil is still cold. You drive and rub metal againt metal in your internals
Warming up the car by driving it will be quicker than warming up by idle. Taking it easy at the start is the key. I don't think we live in a cold enough climate to be warming up our cars. Even so, modern cars shouldn't need to be IMO. You'll save time and money.
Not telling you to start the car and drag race off, now that will wreck havoc to your internals. Otherwise I think it's fine. Of course that's just my opinion and only that. I'm sure there are some useful articles online that may shed some light on this matter.
Back to the oil topic. Our manuals recommend 5w-30 but that's pretty thin for an engine that's done over 200k. I personally would go 40 as I've always done, even on my Accord that's done over 250k.
http://i211.photobucket.com/albums/b...TOXIC/nope.gifQuote:
Originally Posted by H22JET
So wrong.
It actually does more damage to sit and let it idle and warm up for any longer than about a minute.
Heres a post i made a while ago in this thread
http://www.ozhonda.com/forum/showthr...l-warm-up-time
Quote:
Originally Posted by trism
see my dad has a 1.5L civic D15B7 engine, it has done 350,000ks he always lets it warm up and drives good with it the car has never had any problems exept the usual servicng and changing parts as they have done alot of ks - example, water pump, hoses, etc. i thought its known for less internal engine wear if you warm up due to letting the oil warm up while idling instead of driving cold and the oil is still not warmed up to lubricate the internals properly. i always let it warm up a quarter of the temperature then drive off
Seriously mate, do some research. Its a well known fact that its not necessary unless temperatures are well below freezing.
The oil takes 3 times as long to warm up with no load on it. So idling, its doing 3 times the damage as it would if you got in, started up, put on your seat belt, and left.
oh i have done research found alot of positive feedbacks about warming your car up, you cannot do any harm in letting it idle its just idling, if your at peak hour traffic or at traffic lights your car is still idling, it may waste more fuel, but seriously small difference, you drive off cold but your internals are still rubbing metal to metal with not enough lubrication off oil, for what i know let your car warm up to a quarter and drive gently for a few minutes, not letting it full warm up tho
I dont think you are understanding how oils work.
Oil is not like water. It does not run off a surface as soon as you stop circulating it.
Oils are designed so that they cling to surfaces long after it stops being pumped around. As soon as you crank the motor over, it is turning the oil pump, sending oil around the motor. However, there is still a residual layer of oil left on the bores, and on the pistons. Thats why the oil business is worth billions of dollars, because they have the technology to make this happen.
So you crank the motor, and it kicks, and instantly, there is oil circulating around the motor, into the main bearings, around the cam journals, and onto the bore.Instantly.
The reason we have multigrade oils (ie Xw-X) is so that it is thinner when it is cold, allowing it to move around easier. After 30 seconds of running, all of the engines surfaces are sufficiently covered in oil. By sitting there any longer, its causing fuel wash, like i said before, where the excess fuel from the richness of the cold start is scrubbing the oil off the bore, leaving bare metal for the pistons to scrape up against.
If you were to drive off straight away, the engine is under load, so all of this fuel is burnt, and doesnt wash the oil off the bore.
Obviously you arent oging to bounce off the rev limiter, but please, please understand that you can drive after 30 seconds of starting the engine, and it will actually be better for the engine then letting it idle for 5 minutes.
There is a serious difference between letting your car idle to warm up and idling in traffic, the predominant reason being that which i explained earlier, when you start your car up, the engine is in cold start mode, and pumps more fuel in to avoid stalling, which doesnt happen when the car is already warm.
I agree with Trism. Thanks for typing that out and explaining because I wouldn't of bothered and left it at that. I think if someone isn't open to suggestions or ideas other than their own, there is no need to explain further more.
I'm sure you've done your research H22JET, but I think you're ignoring the facts opposing your argument and reading what you want to read. We mean well. At the end of the day, it's your car.
lol.
Any decent car can drive off without problems once you've started the engine for 5-10 seconds. Move off once you've got your seat belt on and everything looks ok on the dashboard. Take it easy on the throttle and keep revs say under 3000rpm.
I have to look my garage in the morning so the most my car idles is about 30 seconds before I drive it off down the road. Never had a problem. Leaving it idling for minutes is just a waste of fuel.
What does concern me are the soccer mums in Camrys/SUVs that start their engines, handbrake down and select Drive all within 2 seconds then floor it off down the road.. LOL
waste of fuel??? dude are you serious??? srsly why would anyone complain about 1 minute worth of fuel are you like a tightass or something bout fuel lol, big deal 1 minute of fuel hardly wastes nothing
You're still wasting fuel for no extra benefits...
Your engine may be warm from idling for up to 5 minutes but everything else is still cold such as the gear box/driveshafts/brakes/tyres etc
The cat convertor after your header/extractors does not work properly if it's cold so for those few minutes your engine is running heaps rich...Stand behind your car after starting it, the smell of the exhaust is bad compared to when everything is at operating temperature.
If you can start driving down the road 10-30 seconds after you've started your car then simply do it...
it's more a concrn of the fuel wash rather than wasting fuel dude, that's just one of the smaller reasons why not to do it.
I give no fark for wasted fuel.
If I was worried about economy I'd drive a hybrid.
The point of the argument, which you seem to be missing, and I keep needed to repeat myself about is that when you warm your car up for any longer than a minute before driving off, you are causing so much more wear to the engine than simply getting in, starting up, and going, while not revving hard until the engine is warm.
The secondary effect, like we keep telling you is that if you warm it up, the engine is warm but every other part of the car is cold, and you think you're right, but you will break stuff .
I've experienced it first hand. A mate with a WRX let his car idle for 5 mins to warm up, then when he took off, boosted it all the way up to the limiter, changed into 2nd, and the gearbox disintegrated.
That's the risk you take.
I just leave my car warm up till a quarter temp and drive slow till its properly warm so everything is all warmed up, never thrash it first 5 minutes, dought that will give me engine wear
also how does it give you fuel wash?
lol, hereQuote:
Originally Posted by H22JET
Quote:
Originally Posted by trism
Its obvious you dont even want to read the information we are giving you in order to help you, so im not even going to bother continuing in this thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by H22JET
just un-friend, problem solved.Quote:
Originally Posted by trism
so, the oil pump takes 5 minutes to work?Quote:
Originally Posted by H22JET
are these articles you read from australia?Quote:
Originally Posted by H22JET
dat no k-swap philosophyQuote:
Originally Posted by ericl33
can't we all just get along? lol
Sorry to Hijack the thread for a second.
I have a 97 BB6 VTIR Lude with only 127xxxkms. just wondering what Oil should I put in?
I am tossing up in between Royal Purple 5w30 or Nulon Full synthetic 5/10w40?
To the OP I recommend with those KM's I wouldnt steer pass nulon 15w40 or even 20w40
My previous owner used Motul Full Synthetic 10w-40
Autobarn and Superchaep reccomended Pentrite
I really want to give Nulon a Chance got told great Aussie company with great oil quality that is under rated
baller! They should be fine unless you're burning already.. cos 5w30's quite thin. i think it's supposed to be 10w30Quote:
Originally Posted by integragsi96
You don't really need a 5wXX oil, 10w will be fine...start off with a 10w30 which is recommended by Honda...go up to 10w40 only if you want to reduce oil burn...anything thicker will place stress on your engine.
Thanks champs!
Royal purple 10w40 it is :p
Nom nom nom purple is the shizz! (tbh ive never used it before lol)
I've used nulon synthetic and penrite synth and nulon seemed to burn like no tomorrow, burnt around 4 litres of oil between an oil change and the penrite seemed to be a bit quieter and burn alot less although this could be because I'm used to the car now and not thrashing it everywhere :P
I've used penrite in past cars and always been happy with their engine and gear oils for the price, can't beat 5 litres of synthetic oil for $45 lol, probs a fair amount worse than motul, royal purple etc but with h22a's burning oil **** putting $100 motul in.
i would stay away from nylon and penrite .
read into these oils and you will understand why.
prelude is best with 10-30 or 10-40 depending on km done
LinkyQuote:
Originally Posted by 08r3308
While the topic is still ripe i will be doing a change on my car which has past 270,000kms,just got it today and Vtec-ed it once on the way home and it was well smokey.
So stick with a 10 40 grade for the old beast and that should curb down oil burning a bit,also wheres best to pick up an oil filter in store,Honda maybe?thanks.
any auto parts store really.. depends on what brand you want etc.Quote:
Originally Posted by Irish R
i'm not going to look into oil filter debates.
Oil filter debates are silly because the differences only start coming into play when the oils been on for too long anyway!
Just saw how much oil I used to use lol, fixed some leaks and would use less than half that now with 5w-30. I'm a bit scared of Nulon because they're so new, Penrite racing 10 sounds good because they're a Class IV synthetic and share the same ingredients as more expensive oils.
I've used Nulon Fully synthetic, penrite synth, penrite racing 10 and edge and they all seem to burn about the same, Been most happy with penrite racing and edge so far (cold starts sound smoother, oil goes darker later and the car is overall smoother all the way to service intervals)
What do you guys think about using 5w-30 on a 180k Healthy H22? Cold starts sound nicer and the car overall drives better but I'm starting to think its a bit thin for its age, hopefully oil consumption will improve somewhat when I fix my final oil seep.
I'd say it's a little thin now, but I was even thinking about trying it myself, I have a healthy f22 and was thinking of trying a thin oil lolQuote:
Originally Posted by wastingtime
If it doesn't burn then there's nothing to worry aboutQuote:
Originally Posted by wastingtime
it's not a H though bor, it's not made of FRMQuote:
Originally Posted by RenzokukenJ
wat n8Quote:
Originally Posted by curtis265
i thought f series got FRM too
only the s2k enginesQuote:
Originally Posted by RenzokukenJ
the rest of them aren't
i had a google, says f22 series have FRM also
Dunno about F22Z lmaao
F22 blocks be made to withstand alot of abuse mayne
Dun make em like dey use to
Been using 10w 40 Nulon Hi Tech for quite sometime . perfect oil and it burns less compared to others. 5w 30 is wayyyy too thin for an engine thats done 200xxx
yeah bought some nulon 10w40 this weekQuote:
Originally Posted by mastermind54
been noticing that my coolant in my radiator is dirty as hell after flushing it 10k ago O_O
I used 10w40 Magnatec when i first bought my prelude but swapped quickly to 5w30 Castrol Edge. The oil usage was very similar and never gave me any issues. My car has done 180,000km now.
I've actually burned minimal amounts since fixing oil leaks (still got a couple to fix) and It still has only used a few hundred ml after 3000km with some harder driving mixed in, I definitely prefer the cold start with a low viscosity oil.
What seals?
onya bro
good to hear