Printable View
I was thinking since many threads seem to go offtopic or get hijacked quite often. I am suggesting a sub section for each state.
That way members/users can simply go to their state's section for quick local advice. Any one agree?
If nothing is done, i was thinking of starting a new Honda forum as this is the only one?
good idea
cos I was going to start an Adelaide forum
this would be much better cos I'm a lazy s*it. hahaha
i vote too to have sections for each state.
that way syd ppl can keep to themselves and not intervine in melb's crap :D:D:D:D:D lolol
Ahhh yess........a valid point and something that I was planning on doing sometime after the forum grew. I guess the only benefit with the current system is that others get to see what's going on in other states without having to go to another forum, however it does all get very confusing!
Also, would this new format be only for events/meets? Because in a lot of other forums, peolpe also put spottings of other members, meets and events in there.
Lets get some feedback!
Sounds like a lot of work...not that I'll be doing any :p
So your idea is to implement this to which forum? The Lounge?
in CRXAustralia we have sections for NSW, Vic, Sa, Qld, WA, Tas/ACT/NT (as there arnt a great deal of members from these states)
basically its a general discussion section for each state, with all threads allowed (beside explicit etc.) whether they be chit chat, events, cruises, spotting, news etc. aslong as it relates to that state its a.ok
having State sections would eliminate the problems that have arouse with cruise threads becoming excessive with general chit chat and 10+ pages, it would also be easier to track cruise discussion threads if they are in state sections and not the lounge as the lounge section is quite active and new threads are started constantly and end up moving current discussion threads to page2 etc. and members not noticing the thread.
would be a very good idea in my opinion.
cruise thread for state based would be good...but i think separating tech knowledge is a bad idea (if anyone is thinking down this path)
I would think this would be in relation to the Events/Outings forum and the lounge to stay as is ?Quote:
Originally Posted by toE
Shouldn't be too hard to implement....just have to move the existing threads over........thats all.
I would be more inclined to add "STATE SECTION" to the main index page of the forum with the listed stakes in the group
I was intending on changing the section called "Events/Outings" to say "Regional", remove the two forums called "Upcoming Events' and "Past events" and put in forums for each of the states there.Quote:
Originally Posted by mr crex
Putting the state forums in the Events/Outings section would limit their use to cruise/meet organisation only wouldnt it? In another section members could also post stuff like "wheres a good place to get a such-and-such?" etc etc
What im saying is, wouldnt there be more uses for the respective state forums other than just cruise/meets?
thats what I am trying to say also.Quote:
Originally Posted by Z
oh come on!!!! I asked for this last year and was dissed!!! :P
nah - definatelly a good idea to have something around each state !
Mike
yea
i am sick of going into a topic with state based jokes of people i dont even know :P
Thanks for your support ppl.
Hopefully something is done about it because i am "too busy" atm to be hosting my own forum.
I rather stick to OH :thumbsup:
How about we have sub sections for the SPOTTED THREAD?...
the Spotted thread is getting a little bit difficult to spot the spots... how bout VIC, NSW, SA, WA sub
sections?.. just a suggestion...
For the state specific sections......I guess it won't be only just meets but also discussions relating to that specific state (EG road rules and things like that).
Maybe in there we can either have a spotted thread (stickied for each state/forum) or just let people post spotted threads as they happen within that (state specific)forum. Only thing with the latter is that it might get pretty messy ?
Lets get some more suggestions/opinions coming so we can finalise this :)
In regards to the state forums getting cluttered with shite, perhaps make guidlines in regards to posting about specific things (in the topic).Quote:
Originally Posted by wynode
eg:
[SPOTTED] so-and-so
[MEET] dd/mm/yyyy
and such and such - similar to the traders forum, where they put their company/name/whatever in the topic.
EDIT: and those who do not follow guidelines will be killed or banned :thumbsup:
LOL yeah
Maybe say strictly that it is only for
1. Meets
2. Spottings
3. State specific discussions ??
Anything else belongs in the lounge ??
:thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by wynode
Your not the admin for nothing. Sound like a plan.
Upcoming events, Past events and the spotted sticky gets the ass in preference of the state forums?
lol Wyn isnt that what Mods are for ;) hahaha
if you just have a specific main section for each state and a mod keeping an eye on the threads like they normally do then should be fine, if a thread is not state based then just move it, if its a current cruise then sticky it.
yups... sounds good.. any unrelated spammage should be deleted for obvious reasons... and ppl who
b*tch bout their post being deleted, too bad fockers.
each state can have there own mod to clean up their states mess.
post can be wateva aslong as it relates to that state.
no need for sticky and all that.
u can't have like 20000 meet stickies and no one can be bother reading through 6million pages in the spotted thread
With that, I think have the state sections for just events and stuff like that, but also, have a specific thread for spottos, don't just let it be willy nilly as you see them because it'll look like the lounge used to look like, too god dam messy! For NSW it will anyway!Quote:
Originally Posted by wynode
I feel sorry for the poor sucker who will police THIS section! Haha.
I'm all for this!Quote:
Originally Posted by wynode
:thumbdwn::thumbdwn::thumbdwn::thumbdwn::thumbdwn: :thumbdwn::thumbdwn:.............
Tell us why you don't want it Trav??
But my issue is that people will start spamming this. Off topic stuff should stay in the lounge, and this section strictly for meets/cruises/spottings (?) and state specific things like road rules etc
that shouldnt be an issue if your mods are doing their job ;)
too right, i told u why win. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by mr crex
u KNOW the solution :thumbsup:
fill us in Trav - as not only Win runs this site - there are several oomp-a-loompas running around here . . . :thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by egSi
how would this be bad??? i see it making it easier to communicate within each state, rather than looking @ a supposed cruise only to find out its in perth. It wont change the communication between members at all
i feel that qld members will turn the 'qld' forum into queensland street car,
a forum full of gay spam :thumbdwn:
Quote:
Originally Posted by egSi
umm......
isnt that every forum - sexual hints in a gay manner , and alot of spam ?!?
Anyway , im keen for a more organised layout 100% too :)
well if its modded harcore then do it, but then ull get members whinging bout mods :rolleyes:
if its properly organised and policed then yeah, but this place is gettin big now and we need more jdm po-po running round :D
Who gets the lucky job of controlling NSW? Haha. :D I controlled a forum once, hard work! And it was half the size! Here it seems all the spammers are in NSW alone!
candidate for nsw... WYNODE ! n his partner in crime BENJI !
Not like they dont have enough to do already! :o
Well, if the supposed event is titled accordingly/appropriately ie. [SYD],[MELB],[ADE],etc., I don't see why you would/wouldn't click on it if you are or are not interested.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Focus
That is why there is a format for posting events up in that forum. :)
so thats what [NSW] means, rofl!:DQuote:
Originally Posted by toE
are you hinting? :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by jes87s
sometimes they arent titled accordingly. It cant be a bad if thing if a worthy mod is nominated for each state and doing their job properly
Or I can step up and title them appropriately (if they aren't) from now on :)
yes but even if it says [NSW] or [ADEL] etc. for a cruise discussion thread doesnt mean it's going to be at the top of the 1st page for people to see, especially in the Lounge section, a cruise discussion thread might go up, then 15 threads about some celebrity showing her **** will send it to page 2, not all of us have the time or effort to go through pages, a state section will clean this up and hopefully keep interstate members from commenting in the threads and turning it into spam.
Just thought i'd upate you guys that the mod team (no not just me LOL) have discussed.....i'm too tired to write it up now but will later!
IMO splitting up states is like segregating up users.
eventually when a VIC user will post in a QLD section (for example), he's gonna get burnt then its all out forum wars. i've seen this happen in the past. although i know most OH members get along with each other well, it may still happen.
!@#$!@# nsw members... *grrr*
that could be a good thing tho, qlders are wankers!! lmfao! :DQuote:
Originally Posted by joyride
i'm all for the idea as long as things are properly controlled by mods. Maybe assign one or two more mods based on regions to police the respective sections?
It's not segregating users to have some state based discussion - It's a good idea and it works well in every forum that has it! Each forum should contain only a few things: a stickied spotted thread, cruise/meet organisation, ANY specifically state-based discussion (such as local autosalon, or local events) even those NOT pertaining specifically to honda (as long as its state based, including parts-for-sale that do NOT offer interstate shipping).
One or two state-specific mods should be assigned to each state with the intention of moving any non-state threads to their appropriate forum.
It would not be segregating users, as general off-topic convo would still be in the lounge - parts for sale should stay where they are - car based discussion would remain in the appropriate car-specific forums. The forums would function as normal, but be easier to access.
That's just my two cents - and I dont see why we wouldn't make this change!
[afterthought - people from interstate should still be able to post in another states forums, naturally assuming its on-topic!]
[afterthought 2 - Most people stick to state-specific threads as it is, since they are the most relevant]
I am very happy with the set up at the moment, having the State forums and model specific will get to spread out I think.
Thats what I have also been trying to get accross with specific models of cars - title [EG], [EK], [ED Civic], [ED/EF Crx] makes everything so much cleaner and more organised.Quote:
Originally Posted by toE
Hand Up here for WA :thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by nedgeworth
i reckon have state sections that include stickies for spotted, upcoming cruises and weekly meets. then also have cruise eoi's, and state by state news like like police hotspots or road regulations etc
(i havent really thought it out but thats what came to mind atm)
other than that i dont really see a problem with how it is now.
Without state sections, the "spotted" thread is pretty much limited to NSW only, since nobody else bothers to check it... which sucks.
Also What people dont seem to be understanding is that nobody wants to sift through several pages of threads to find something relevant to their state.
for NSW im sure its fine since theres always 20 threads relevant to them, but for others it becomes a hassle.
The current way works, yes, but its just not good enough.
Sorry about the late reply but i've brought it up with the other mods and we've decided to keep it the way it is, except for a possible "EOI" forum for cruises.
Reason being is that based on other sites that have a similar setup, things get quite messy and hard to moderate. As long as we precede the thread title with the location (for example [BRIS]) things should be OK. If anyone would like to put their hand up to moderate the existing events section post back or PM me.
If you havea look at these sites for example
Pulsar Group Australia
CRX Australia
Skylines Australia
That's fair enough. Not my cup of tea, but I'm not an admin!... yet :cool:
I seem to think its best with some sort of state specific forum.
This is one of the most organised forums ive ever seen:
http://forum.r31skylineclub.com/
State specific works perfectly there! they're a decent sized (and very active) club, who are not segregated at all! There's nothing wrong with having somewhere to easily access threads specific to your state
*puts hand up*Quote:
Originally Posted by wynode
i'm on enough, it may as well be constructive;)
get ppl to nominate and have a vote going.
I like the idea
'the tribe has spoken'Quote:
Originally Posted by wynode
well you guys can always have a test site. see how it goes for a month or so.
if its gettin out of hand, then scrap it, if its succesfull then keep it etc etc
:P