I start first, i think the tranny is the biggest handicap,if we have same tranny between vti r and DC4, i don't think vti r can beat DC4. can anyone else list others. :)
Printable View
I start first, i think the tranny is the biggest handicap,if we have same tranny between vti r and DC4, i don't think vti r can beat DC4. can anyone else list others. :)
If this is the caseQuote:
Originally Posted by sydteg21
why didnt honda just make a GSi with better tranny?
why did honda came out with the the VTiR instead..
and later developed that into a Type R?
you think a vtir can't beat a gsi with the same transmission?
handicap would be the non-vtec motor unless it's heavily modified...
Quote:
Originally Posted by sydteg21
LOL
LOL
LOL
LOL
LOL
LOL
LOL
Your soo funny!
VTEC!
Tranny doesnt add 20kw.
:thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by kOncept
Sorry if this has been answered but just to make sure does the GSi have the same tranny as the VTi-R?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix
Ture ture..haha
sorry, my bad, i didn't actually mean that, not same tranny ,i meant similar quality (maybe better one)sorry, BTW i used to beat a vti-r with stock gsi and type R tranny.sorry guys
how bout driver !? or maybe a slipping clutch ? or maybe you have better tyres then them. or maybe they have exhaust problems. ?!
What difference does having a type r tranny in a GSi make?
it makes a lot of different, specially with the one which has LSD,shift is shorter,you can get more speed from each gear (first gear is same, difference starts from the 2nd gear, GSI second gear is really weak) due to the higher ratios.
tranny does make the car a whole lot faster, most europeans cars rely on the tranny more than the engine. while jap cars are more engine based.
Haveing a Type R Transmission in a GSI is not going to make the GSI quicker than a Type R or even a VTiR. And thats that!
If you beat type R's and Vtir's in your GSI, then i'd suggest that the other drivers either - can't drive or they weren't trying to race you, OR they had a car full of fat people.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GreekWarrior
Nothing to overall power, just make the shifts and the take off SLIGHTLY quicker.
if that's the case ,why people bother to pay thousands of dollar to change a type r or B16 tranny ,they can just get a short shifter to achieve the fact you said
Because the box is stronger and ratios slightly diferent, and because the "feel" is much better.
And if you have killed your GSI box then since you gotta replace it you might as well get a type R box, or if your going to do track work then a stronger gearbox is required (such as in my case). That would be why there is people upgrading to type R boxes, or they might have other mods done that will complement having a type R gear box..
If you think your going to be quicker then a vtir or as quick as a type r, because you have type r tranny, then your wrong.
Is it worth putting a type r tranny in a GSi?
dc4 is teh gay .
If you can justify spending a couple of grand for a slightly stronger and better feeling gearbox. So the answer is probably - No.Quote:
Originally Posted by GreekWarrior
to all you gsi owners out there you have the lowest of all 90's model tegs. you wont beat a v-tir or type under same sercumstances. e.g drivers ability and cars overall condition. why do you think honda spent all that money developing v-tec. i have a dc2 and dont go saying that i can beat a type R because they probably weren't trying. Stick a turbo on it and get back to us.
(sorry to all those realistic gsi owners i have just offended)
when did i say that i beat a type r? use your brain to think type R has type r tranny and vtec, the one i used has type r tranny with lsd and nearly stock gsi body. HTF can i beat a type r without modifying internal
ok so kool
I suggest you all download a program call "CarTest".
You will find that slapping a B16/GSR/Type-R gearbox on an LS (B18A/B) motor will give you hardly any performance at all. You will just have to change gears earlier, it will be a pain in the ass.
Close ratio's are good, not short ratios. You will be faster off the line as you will get to the upper rpm range faster, but thats where it ends.
When you start to make serious power, even n/a, in an LS it is just stupid to have a short ratio gearbox, you will get serious traction problems, even with an LSD.
GreekWarrior: Is your car seriously 1146kg? Thats insane. I took my 90 LS to the weighbridge the other day and it weighed in at 1060kg with spare and 15kg of fuel... What the hell is in a DC2/4?
Doesn't matter, i don't really want to argue that. I'm just want to discuss it. If i did offense some vti-r owner, i say sorry here.
Again with the GSi bashing, lol.
WE KNOW WE DONT HAVE FRICKING V-TEC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
GSi's are what we have and we are dealing with it.
However, there is not a huge difference in quater mile times with the vti-r. Obviously it's a more powerful car, who gives a sh*t. With the engineering advantage of the V-tec engine how could it not be.
Some ppl buy a GSi for a reason i.e. the young ones for insurance problems, power nuts for boosting and for ppl who would never hit 8000rpm because they just want a reliable daily driver.
In my opinion, Honda f**ked up, why go backwards in technology for one series of car?!? If i had known anything about honda's when i bought my car i probably would have gone for a v-tec model, but, sh*t happens, i got a GSi.
So...To all the vti-r owners or type r owners who think we dont know your car can be faster, go for a drive in a car that actually IS considered quick and then think about how important your extra 20 odd kw's are.
**end rant**
hmm lots of 1996 dc4 owners here..mad!
Quote:
Originally Posted by bennyBear
Some people dont realise this, they think with a tranny upgrade that they will be as quick as the vtec models.
well dc2s are running mid 15s
and ive seen some dc4s running the same time..
i dont see why it cant be as quick
vtec isnt everything
I didnt know there was DC2's running mid 15s?
I ran 14.9 with a crappy take off (had a worn clutch) on street tires, with a very large suitcase full of clothes in the boot that i had forgotten to take out.
GSI's doing mid 15's are they stock.?
VTIR's doing mid 15's must be stock and or have crap drivers.
That's what the user manual said so I don't.Quote:
Originally Posted by string
Anyway I would just like to point out that I'm am just asking about putting a typr r tranny in a GSi , I'm not out to try and "beat" a vti-r or type r. If adding a type r tranny to GSi was enough to "beat" or be as fast as a vti-r/type r then honda would have failed in their original mission which was to create a faster integra.
I've driven my mates old GSi teg, its not that much slower than the VTi-R models.
sorry to all i offended late long day and not the first time i have been told a dc4 can beat a dc2 I didn't spend an extra $5000 to end up with the same car. I was only reacting to a comment made by a previous post. an approx sec in a quater mile for cars is a big difference.
lol ok so your sayin a your vtir is close to even/quicker then a type r !!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix
and that time is like .. one in a trillion..
but you cant accept that a gsi can be as quick as a vtir
and yes i know of at least 4 or 5 gsi's running 15.4 - 15.6
Even 0.5 seconds is a big difference in quarter mile languageQuote:
Originally Posted by mugenman
guys trannys make a difference when your drag racing. i dont know about power but dragging it does make a diff. i know cos i been in a car with a type R box then they swapped it over to the b16
I give up, lol.
(pulls hair out)
Remembering the whole 'people in glass houses' thing, i wouldn't have thought that any Honda owner (short of s2k/nsx or heavy mods) would be full of themselves, thats one of the reasons i joined this site, to get away from the bagging that comes with owning a relatively slow car!!!!!!!!!
MEH!!!
u left itr's out :( why?
btw do any other honda owners find themselves defending honda's till death against criticism from mates? lol i just find it funny how even though i know that type r's won't outrun an s15 on a straight, or sound better than a rexy with an exhaust or have the torque of a 5.7L clubbie, i still claim its better lol!
Quote:
Originally Posted by FR33K
What, theres heaps of vtirs doing high 14sec.
I never said that my vtir is quicker then a type R. I know its not.
I'd think that GENERALLY type R's do low to mid 14s, vtirs do high 14s low 15s and GSI's do high 15s.
Stock.
you just said that you ran 14.9 in your stock vtir
but your timeslip database says headers exhaust !!
on a private track ?? did u use a stopwatch ??
Quote:
Originally Posted by FR33K
I didn't say i did it stock. No not a stopwatch. My uncle has a proper drag strip setup on his property. With sensor timers (dont know exactly how acurate it is, he swears by it). He lives about 5hrs drive away though. I did that run last time i was there. Should be going back there at the end of oct. will do another run then.
in mod world ,it is always that you get what you pay for, i don't think people pay over 2000 bucks to get a second hand type R tranny with LSD just for a strongger gear, some people say there is no that much difference between the stock gsi tranny and type r tranny with LSD on a gsi. So just want to ask if you guys have tried in real case or just think that should be like that. i experienced that. i have to say LSD makes huge difference and the car definitely goes fast and rev quicker and higher (with the aftermarket cam will be perfect) shift is shorter, maybe i should try to borrow the car from my friend to do a 1/4 mile, however his car is not stock with tranny anymore,damn.
I did use to beat a vti-r (only one person in the car and a young driver)on a flat road even you guy thinks maybe driver is too fat or crappy or doesn't want race........... i can tell you he wanted to race, after light changed to green ,we both stared pretty quickly cos i know he was riding the cluthch so was i. Ok just assume i can't beat it on a flat road, how about down slope then, same quality driver one is stock vti-r and the other stock gsi with TYPE R tranny with LSD ,which one do you think is quicker.
I really did not mean to offense vti-r ,it is a good honda car for sure, i would get one too if my girlfriend didn't write off our previous car without comprehensive insurance,was her fault. she has shadow in her heart now, she can't drive without a insurance, so we have to get a comprehensive insurance. MY insurance is 3300 dollars for GSI, vtec one i have to pay over 4000 dollars, Just rediculous expensive in sydney, don't really want to pay that much : )
I'm here to discuss the my case, not arguing, i didn't say vti-r is not a good car, how ever somebody said DC4 is teg gay, really disapointed with that person, if 30 or 60 hp different makes you think our car is a gay, how about compare my previous GTR33 with your car, 200hp difference what you expect me to think your car is .
We are here to learn more knowledge, not attack each other, we should respect each other. if i did make some vti-r drivers think that i'm offensing them, i say sorry again .
i think ppl are forgetting here about the torque output of these engines,
and torque is what makes your car move.
B18B2 1834cc DOHC 172Nm@5200 101kw@6300
B18C1 1834cc 81x87.2 DOHC VTEC 173Nm@6200 127kw@7300
the vtir needs the higher ratios to stay in its power band, and i personaly think the gsi doesnt as it makes it power down low,
25kw is alot of difference but what power is the vtir making at 6300?
and how much torque is it making at 5200?
how would a b18b perform if you matched its low 9.2 comp ratio to equal the b18c.
lets not forget itr too
B18C7 1797cc 11.1 81x87.2 DOHC VTEC 178Nm@6300 141kw@7900
vtir isnt 1834 ?? its 1797 cc as well
Torque doesn't make your car move.
A faster car will be faster because it produces more power over the same ammount of time. A type-r tranny on a GSI will give you a little bit more area under the curve per gear, which will make you faster.
LSD will not make you any faster in a straight unless you have seriously crappy tyres or a rediculous ammount of power.
so what you are saying is that torque is useless??
well lets compare a s15 aus spec to s2000?
147kw to 176kw and 279nm to 208nm.
tell me which car spanks the other in a straight line?
torque is what makes a car move!!!
specialy up a hill.
So why don't huge trucks accelerate quickly up hills? They have more torque than you can poke a stick at.
When did I mention that torque was useless. Torque is a parameter of power, and is a null point when it comes down to speed. It is all to do with area under the power curve, torque is irrelevent unless you are talking about torque * rpm, which is power.
You cannot compare two cars based on peak power numbers alone; You also failed to take into account weight, though, you are lucky the two cars are quite similar in weight (albeit S15 is lighter).
Your comparing a turbo engine with a head design where volumetric efficiency drops off at a similar level to the B18. You will hit peak power earlyish and then it will hold as the rpm rises.
Then you are comparing this to a high revving n/a engine, where the typical power curve is a straight line.
What has more area, a rectangle or a triangle which is 20% taller....
Do the maths.
(Obviously my example is rather exaggerated, since it will give 60% more area for the S15, but if you compare the two actual graphs, you will get the idea...)
MAAAAAN get over the bitchiness guys, put it this way, a vtir is a slightly more powerful car than a gsi full stop, given both have no modifications at all to either!!!! CANT argue with that. I own a gsi and have raced vtir tegs with success OK. mayb i was the better driver, maybe i had the better take off, what ever. BUT just dont go thinking that VTEC is a frikn jet engine that could keep up with F1 cars lol. for gods sake its only 20kw at the fly wheel. You get the better take off with a lsd type r tranny and i can guarantee the vtir wil not catch up in a short race from one light to another in a lil drag race(not talking about freeway conditions here!!??) its not like when vtec kicks in, ur tyres keep spinning all the way to fifth gear coz ur so powerful and have 30 psi running within ur setup. get a life!!! Simple is simple vtir slightly more powerful than gsi given all variables are the same.
for e.g. Gsi with a proper exhaust system and a cai will sure b a quicker car in performance than a stock vtir because of quicker acceleration etc etc
Go GSi! :D
SLIK_TEG,
okay lets be a little more resonable. If you put a dc2r lsd, full cat back system and a cai into both a gsi, and a vtir, the difference would only become greater, IE. dc2 >> then dc4.
Lets not compare a moded car vs a stock car,
either equal mods to both cars, or both stock.
When both cars are stock there is a 20kw difference in power (keep that in mind).
Modded, who knows.
btw, if changing the tranny is all you needed to do i don't see why there's a lack of aftermarket support for the b18b ? (dc4)
LOL!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by SLIK_TEG
thats hilarious!
must be about two in a trillion now. booget did a 14.9 with a cat back and cai, with a boot full of crap and 17's too- not to mention his totally cactus transmission. :thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by FR33K
14.9 is pretty goddamn easy in a vti-r.
Link to the timeslip where you ran a 14.9 easily?Quote:
Originally Posted by ginganggooly
lol @ DC4 vs DC2 argument... *laughs at how (some) DC2 owners are overly defensive*
http://www.ozhonda.com/forum/member....ails&userid=84
http://www.ozhonda.com/forum/member....ails&userid=99
http://www.ozhonda.com/forum/member....ls&userid=4597
http://www.ozhonda.com/forum/member....ils&userid=905
And this ones the slowest recorded Integra Vtir @ 15.257
http://www.ozhonda.com/forum/member....ils&userid=530
but the whole point in this thread is to compare a stock vti-r with a stock gsi type r tranny with LSD. gsi has a better tranny and doesn't have vtec, i admit stock vti-r is faster than gsi. And who said there is a lack of aftermarket support b18b? never feel that way. FELIX all the vti-rs you got are modified (not stock).And i know some stock gsi did 15.4, and type r tranny with lsd will definitely give a better launch ,rev and shorter shifter ,so .....
I was talking about booget...Quote:
Originally Posted by string
The slowest i've run is a 14.8, but i'm a little less stock than booget. Look at the timeslip database if you want more details.
I know, i was just providing the link that string asked for.
i see no slips??
i ran 15.6 in stock gsi and i have a slip to prove it.
even if i ran a 14.8 or .9 still not really a time that you would use to bag a car running .7 of a second slower.
the slowest 1 is the only 1 with the slip?
i done a 12sec run on a gtech last night i might post that up!
As stated, mine was done on a private track, allthough the track contained all the nessessary gear to get an accurate time there was no print out.
I live around 3hrs drive from a drag track. so its not easy for me to get an official one done.
Quote:
Originally Posted by locote
.7 of a second is alot when traveling at around 145+km per hour...
is that directed at me?Quote:
Originally Posted by locote
if so- i've not bagged anyone here yet, i couldn't be arsed scanning and posting my timeslip. do you not believe me?
HI locote, you did pretty well, just wondering when you shift your gear, i normally change it around 4000(sometimes 6000 just being a idiot) : ) with mine,the one with type r tranny i shft around 5000
if thats when your shifting then your not even reaching peak power...Quote:
Originally Posted by sydteg21
a crap launch can make you more than a second slower!
and you wouldnt even know it till u see ur slip!!!
and i dont care if you guys can run high 14s in your cars, 14s is f all,
and y should you guys get so defensive over the vtir being half a second quiker?
you paid more for your car, it was more expensive when it came out, thats obvious for a reason, the motor is different, it has more power so therefore it has to be quiker than a gsi.
if some 1 chose a gsi over a vtir why should you go and bag them and say that their car is half a second slower than your's over 400m, you paid the extra 1000s for that half a second and you shouldnt have to bag the ppl who didnt because they simply didnt think half a second was worth it.
just before 7k mate,
but now i shift at 6500 not worth redlineing it
mind you last time i went i only ran constant 15.8s
but i changed my exhaust to 2.5'
and its way to big for a b18b so all my torque is gone.
but im turboing soon so ill be saying hello to 13s :)
i peak at 6200 at the moment
And also i like to point out another major handicap for DC4,that is the camshaft. B18B has a really strong block,it is a really potential engine ,however the cams limit the potential a lot. I'm going for the all-motor since a lot of people think DC4 is slow and personally don't like turbo and supercharge is too expensive in australia. i'm currently changing suspension, camshaft will be my next step with IM and TB with a ECU, one of my friends in US owns a integra LS faster than a type r ,188whp i think it is pretty cool : )
cool, i never run 1/4 mile, just run for the lights ,don't want to go too crazy, as i mentioned before type r tranny one is my friend's, didn't really want to redline it or somewhere up 6000, i think i changed aroud 5500 to 5800 when i was racing the vti-r ,could not really remeber .
http://www.ozhonda.com/gallery/water...4timeslips.JPG
In case it looked like i was arse-blowing :o
how much would it cost anways? changing the tranny from vtir to type r? inclusing lsd
you dont need to prove your self to any one.
i never daughted that you could run those times.
but some ppl think that using a gtech or a stop watch is same and going to the real track. and its not.
probarbly worth it if you killed your transmition, but not as an upgrade value for money just wouldnt be there i think.
i rather go out and buy a after market lsd which is what im goin to do.
im looking at KAAZ atm 2000 installed and a lot better than a ITR lsd
Guys Suck On This Shit My Gsi Done 14.3 Qtr Mile. People Who Know Me And Some People On This Forum Inclusing Fai Jai Know This. i had a gsr engine though. us version of vtir.
my mate had a vtir engine in his eg civic done 14.4! just exhaust mods.
but yes, gsi is a strong car! for a normal 1.8l
sweet :thumbsup:
Bo yeah! :honda: :DQuote:
Originally Posted by fly_vti